ConductScience.org, home

Paper19396166

Circular analysis in systems neuroscience: the dangers of double dipping.

Kriegeskorte N and 3 others. Nat Neurosci, 2009. Cited by 2,116 papers, by iCite.

Cite this record

ConductScience Library. Circular analysis in systems neuroscience: the dangers of double dipping. Papers, record 19396166. Release papers-2026-11-12-0.1.0, 12 Nov 2026. https://conductscience.org/library/papers/19396166

Download JSON
Sources
11 sources
Release
papers-2026-11-12-0.1.0

Paper

PubMed's record of the paper, with iCite's citation figures. No abstract is shown.

Title
Circular analysis in systems neuroscience: the dangers of double dipping.
PubMed
Journal
Nat Neurosci
PubMed
Year
2009
PubMed
Publication types
Journal Article, Research Support, N.I.H., Intramural, Review
PubMed
Citations, by iCite
2,116
iCite
Relative citation ratio, by iCite
62.8
iCite
Revised in PubMed
2025-05-29
PubMed

Authors4

The authors in the order PubMed's record lists them, with the ORCID iDs it states.

OrderAuthorForenameKindORCID iD
1Kriegeskorte NNikolaus
2Simmons WKW Kyle
3Bellgowan PSPatrick S F
4Baker CIChris I

Source PubMed

Download CSV of authors

Topics11

NLM's MeSH indexing of the paper, its major topics first.

MeSH termMajor
NeurosciencesMajor topic
Animals
Artifacts
Data Collection
Data Interpretation, Statistical
Humans
Image Processing, Computer-Assisted
Magnetic Resonance Imaging
Reproducibility of Results
Selection Bias
Systems Biology

Source PubMed

Download CSV of topics

Grants1

Each grant PubMed's record writes, matched to the NIH project NIH's grant and paper links name for this paper, and each of those links the record does not write.

Grant, as the record writes itAgencyCountryNIH projectStated by
ZIA MH002909Intramural NIH HHSUnited StatesZIAMH002909PubMed and NIH

Source NIH RePORTER

Download CSV of grants

Trials2

The trials whose ClinicalTrials.gov record lists the paper, and the trial numbers the paper's PubMed record names.

TrialTitleThe trial lists it asNamed in the paper's recordSource
NCT01861405Neurococognitive and Functioal Assessment of Patients With Brain MetastasesBackgroundClinicalTrials.gov
NCT03766191Genetic Predisposition to Food Cue Reactivity in ChildrenBackgroundClinicalTrials.gov

Download CSV of trials

Comments and corrections1

PubMed's comments and corrections, NLM's own indexing: retractions first, then expressions of concern, errata and updates, and comments last.

KindPMIDTitleIn Papers
Comment in31011228Double-dipping revisited.https://conductscience.org/library/papers/31011228

Source PubMed

Download CSV of comments and corrections

References15

The papers the reference list in PubMed's record names, those in our copy of PubMed, in the list's order.

OrderPMIDTitleJournalYearIn PapersSource
112814577Functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) "brain reading": detecting and classifying distributed patterns of fMRI activity in human visual cortex.Neuroimage2003https://conductscience.org/library/papers/12814577PubMed
211906227Thresholding of statistical maps in functional neuroimaging using the false discovery rate.Neuroimage2002https://conductscience.org/library/papers/11906227PubMed
316635578Divide and conquer: a defense of functional localizers.Neuroimage2006https://conductscience.org/library/papers/16635578PubMed
41400644A three-dimensional statistical analysis for CBF activation studies in human brain.J Cereb Blood Flow Metab1992https://conductscience.org/library/papers/1400644PubMed
511577229Distributed and overlapping representations of faces and objects in ventral temporal cortex.Science2001https://conductscience.org/library/papers/11577229PubMed
69343600Analysis of fMRI time-series revisited--again.Neuroimage1995https://conductscience.org/library/papers/9343600PubMed
719396166Circular analysis in systems neuroscience: the dangers of double dipping.Nat Neurosci2009https://conductscience.org/library/papers/19396166PubMed
826158964Puzzlingly High Correlations in fMRI Studies of Emotion, Personality, and Social Cognition.Perspect Psychol Sci2009https://conductscience.org/library/papers/26158964PubMed
917189940Does the fusiform face area contain subregions highly selective for nonfaces?Nat Neurosci2007https://conductscience.org/library/papers/17189940PubMed
1016635579A critique of functional localisers.Neuroimage2006https://conductscience.org/library/papers/16635579PubMed
1115501090Optimizing the fMRI data-processing pipeline using prediction and reproducibility performance metrics: I. A preliminary group analysis.Neuroimage2004https://conductscience.org/library/papers/15501090PubMed
1216537458Information-based functional brain mapping.Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A2006https://conductscience.org/library/papers/16537458PubMed
1311906218The quantitative evaluation of functional neuroimaging experiments: the NPAIRS data analysis framework.Neuroimage2002https://conductscience.org/library/papers/11906218PubMed
1414599004Controlling the familywise error rate in functional neuroimaging: a comparative review.Stat Methods Med Res2003https://conductscience.org/library/papers/14599004PubMed
1516899397Beyond mind-reading: multi-voxel pattern analysis of fMRI data.Trends Cogn Sci2006https://conductscience.org/library/papers/16899397PubMed

Download CSV of references

Cited by1,438

The papers in our copy of PubMed whose reference list names this one, newest first. iCite, which reads more sources, counts 2,116 citations.

PMIDTitleJournalYearIn PapersSource
42982783Counteracting the overestimation of effect size in mass-univariate brain-wide association studies using cross-validation.Transl Psychiatry2026https://conductscience.org/library/papers/42982783PubMed
42973962Cerebrospinal fluid TNF-α, regional degree centrality, and depressive symptoms after herpes simplex encephalitis: a cross-sectional observational study.Front Neurol2026https://conductscience.org/library/papers/42973962PubMed
42970031Action observation and sensorimotor brain activity following drumming training: a longitudinal fMRI study.Exp Brain Res2026https://conductscience.org/library/papers/42970031PubMed
42964840Interbrain synchrony analysis for fNIRS: A signal processing primer.Imaging Neurosci (Camb)2026https://conductscience.org/library/papers/42964840PubMed
42963523Neural mechanisms underlying the effects of cognitive fatigue on physical effort-based choice.Cogn Affect Behav Neurosci2026https://conductscience.org/library/papers/42963523PubMed
42958247Unsupervised machine learning for clinical risk subtyping and re-fracture risk analysis in osteoporotic vertebral compression fractures.BMC Surg2026https://conductscience.org/library/papers/42958247PubMed
42955542Graph Neural Network Reveals the Cortical Morphology of Local Brain Aging in Normal Cognition and Alzheimer's Disease.Neuroinformatics2026https://conductscience.org/library/papers/42955542PubMed
42943164Microbiome-Associated Regulation of Isoquinoline Alkaloids in Sinomenium acutum Reveals Functional Endophytes for Sinomenine Accumulation.Plants (Basel)2026https://conductscience.org/library/papers/42943164PubMed
42939273Distinct Nodal Centrality and Connectivity Profiles Underlying Independent and Interdependent Self-Construal: A Graph-Theoretical Resting-State fMRI Study.Brain Sci2026https://conductscience.org/library/papers/42939273PubMed
42929684Dynamics of individual visual biases in space and time.J Vis2026https://conductscience.org/library/papers/42929684PubMed
42925098Response to Letter to the Editor Regarding "Outcome Selection before Multiplicity Correction May Overstate Neuroimaging Evidence in Adolescent Scoliosis".Global Spine J2026https://conductscience.org/library/papers/42925098PubMed
42925096Outcome Selection before Multiplicity Correction May Overstate Neuroimaging Evidence in Adolescent Scoliosis.Global Spine J2026https://conductscience.org/library/papers/42925096PubMed
42877574The late positive component in recognition memory is linked to mnemonic evidence accumulation.Imaging Neurosci (Camb)2026https://conductscience.org/library/papers/42877574PubMed
42867319Decoding object categories from electroencephalography during free viewing reveals early information evolution compared to passive viewing.J Vis2026https://conductscience.org/library/papers/42867319PubMed
42832527Moral and perceptual conflict processing are implemented by distinct brain activation and functional connectivity patterns.PLoS Biol2026https://conductscience.org/library/papers/42832527PubMed
42827699Fit one model, report one number: how to analyse a training or intervention study.Front Physiol2026https://conductscience.org/library/papers/42827699PubMed
42819998EBA-related body-preferring responses in the occipitotemporal cortex measured with functional near-infrared spectroscopy.Front Hum Neurosci2026https://conductscience.org/library/papers/42819998PubMed
42818909Cortical Network Reorganization During Balance Control in Chronic Stroke: Premotor-Parietal Behavioral Uncoupling and Directional Prefrontal Compensation.medRxiv2026https://conductscience.org/library/papers/42818909PubMed
42806157The mediating effect of neuroticism on the association between brain signal variability in the prefrontal cortex and depression among healthy individuals.Brain Imaging Behav2026https://conductscience.org/library/papers/42806157PubMed
42781291Distinct value-modulated connectomic signatures during monetary incentive anticipation predict severity and craving in internet gaming disorder.Int J Clin Health Psychol2026https://conductscience.org/library/papers/42781291PubMed

See all 1,438 cited byDownload CSV of cited by

Data dates

The date of each source this release read.

PubMed
2026-11-06
PubMed
iCite
2026-11-05
iCite
PMC's ID file
2026-11-05
PMC's ID file
NIH RePORTER's grant and paper links
2026-11-01
NIH RePORTER's grant and paper links
Trials
2026-11-12
Gene search
2026-11-11
Pipelines
2026-09-18

None in this release

  • Genes
  • Drugs
  • Data

Sources 11

  • ChEMBL, through Open TargetsCC BY-SA 3.0
  • ClinicalTrials.govNo license stated
  • HGNCCC0
  • iCiteCC BY 4.0
  • NCBI GenePublic domain (US government)
  • NIH RePORTER's grant and paper linksPublic domain
  • Open TargetsCC0 1.0
  • PMC's ID filePublic domain (US government)
  • PubMedNLM's terms
  • PubTator 3Public domain
  • UniProtCC BY 4.0
Each source's terms
  • ChEMBL, through Open TargetsCC BY-SA 3.0, for the parts from ChEMBL. Read on 8 Nov 2026 at https://platform-docs.opentargets.org/licence
  • ClinicalTrials.govnone stated
  • HGNCCC0: https://www.genenames.org/about/license/
  • iCiteCC BY 4.0
  • NCBI GeneNone named for the file. NCBI says information created by or for the US government on its site is in the public domain, and asks that NLM be acknowledged: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/home/about/policies/
  • NIH RePORTER's grant and paper linksPublic domain (NIH RePORTER)
  • Open TargetsCC0 1.0. Open Targets asks that users cite its latest paper: Buniello et al. 2025, Open Targets Platform: facilitating therapeutic hypotheses building in drug discovery, Nucleic Acids Research 53(D1):D1467, PMID 39657122. Read on 8 Nov 2026 at https://platform-docs.opentargets.org/licence
  • PMC's ID fileNone named for the file. NCBI says information created by or for the US government on its site is in the public domain, and asks that NLM be acknowledged: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/home/about/policies/
  • PubMedNLM's terms
  • PubTator 3Public domain
  • UniProtCC BY 4.0. UniProt's licence file: "All databases and documents in the UniProt FTP directory may be copied and redistributed freely, without advance permission, provided that this copyright statement is reproduced with each copy." UniProt asks that users cite its latest paper: The UniProt Consortium, UniProt: the Universal Protein Knowledgebase in 2025, Nucleic Acids Research 53:D609-D617, https://doi.org/10.1093/nar/gkae1010. Read on 9 Nov 2026 at https://www.uniprot.org/help/license

ClinicalTrials.gov's data carry an international copyright outside the United States: https://clinicaltrials.gov/about-site/terms-conditions.

For software

Read this paper from software.

The record and each of its lists are JSON, twenty rows a page. No key.

GET https://conductscience.org/api/papers/v1/19396166

GET https://conductscience.org/api/papers/v1/19396166/cited_by?page=2